~sircmpwn/aerc2#420: 
Use existing gpg keyring / support smarcards

I was initially going to ask only about smartcard support but I guessed it was a broader issue.

From what I've read either in #358, #353 or in lib/keystore.go#L19, I understand that the PGP implementation is based on a custom keyring. Please tell me if I'm mistaken.

I think integrating with the existing gpg keyring if it exists and gpg is installed would be a better idea as we would benefit from all the goodies it has to offer, like support for smartcards for example.

Status
RESOLVED WONT_FIX
Submitter
~crocmagnon
Assigned to
No-one
Submitted
3 months ago
Updated
a month ago
Labels
pgp

~crocmagnon 3 months ago

Maybe a duplicate of #356 but it's not detailed so it's not very easy to know for sure.

~araspik 3 months ago

I'm thinking of implementing this as an input filter, by adding support for filters to output MIME. It would then only require a simple gpg --decrypt command to get this working. However, that would effectively remove aerc's first-class PGP support, by making it an external feature. As such, I'm not sure how to proceed. Any thoughts?

~crocmagnon 3 months ago

IMO relying on existing and established tools such as gpg would be the best way to provide support for these features without requiring too much development effort (I guess) and without having to reinvent the wheel.

Also, users with existing keyrings would have a much nicer experience since it would allow them to use what they already have and not have a separate tool to manage when importing keys and trusting them.

~sircmpwn REPORTED WONT_FIX 3 months ago

I'm not interested in using gpg. Developer effort is not the concern, quality is the concern. There are 100 bad email clients which would be swayed by the developer effort argument, but aerc is not one of them.

We discussed gpg in detail in #aerc-dev a few days ago. Under no circumstances is gpg support going to be added to aerc; we intend to continue developing our internal keyring.

~crocmagnon 3 months ago

Thanks for your answer. Is smartcard support planned then? As it was my original issue I could reopen a ticket for this specific use case.

~sircmpwn 3 months ago

No, I don't intend to support smartcards any time soon. That'll come after PGP is generally implemented and stable.

~crocmagnon referenced this from #424 3 months ago

~ctrm referenced this from #446 a month ago

Register here or Log in to comment, or comment via email.